So, if you happen to visit Tumblr or own a Tumblr blog, my guess is that you check the Xenogears tag once in a while. Recently, someone (of jewish heritage/religion) criticized the game for handling jewish references badly and gratuitously (as well as Xenosaga... Xenoblade, however, was praised).
For example, the various cities/nations named after jewish months ? Do you think the use of "Kislev", "Av", "Shevat" or "Nisan" are meaningful within the storyline ? I've never seen anyone in the fandom try to dig into this. Usually, websites just specify "named after months in the jewish calendar" and stop there.
After seeing this person on Tumblr kind of attack the game about its use of jewish names/references... it led me to do a few researches on my own. I went on various jewish websites and actually... I found some interesting stuff.
Nisan is a good example of what I'm talking about.
Another interesting page about Nisan : http://www.hebrew4christians.com/Holidays/Spring_Holidays/Rosh_Chodashim/rosh_chodashim.html
From what I gathered from searching multiple websites, "Nisan" is about "miracles", "redemption", "rebirth", "salvation", "deliverance", "spring", "flowers"... In Xenogears, the town is a religious center and becomes a place of salvation, of hope in disc 2. And its current leader is named Marguerite (this is a flower name). Not only that, but Nisan (and its leader Sophia... aka Elly... aka the one with the WE/God's will) was fighting a war for freedom against Solaris. "Nisan" is the first month in the jewish calendar as its represents jewish people's freedom from their oppressors (egyptians/pharaoh). As for rebirth... maybe Sophia "coming back" in the game illustrates this.
I could talk about the other months in details (I found out that there was a connection between Tammuz and Ezekiel... in short it's a "people worship this ancient god Tammuz and God gets angry about it" story... Ezekiel is the messenger... in Xenogears, Ezekiel is the name of the ship that attacks the Thames/Tammuz and the Ethos... I guess the Gazel = God, Ethos = the "unfaithful believers" and Thames = the "pagan" god/idol... since the Ethos was in partnership with the Thames to gather enough power to overthrow Solaris)... but I'm a bit tired and I'd like to know what you think about this.
- Spoiler:
- This person also recently shut me down while I was trying to discuss with him/her . Whatever. Typical of tumblr "us versus them" mentality these days...
For example, the various cities/nations named after jewish months ? Do you think the use of "Kislev", "Av", "Shevat" or "Nisan" are meaningful within the storyline ? I've never seen anyone in the fandom try to dig into this. Usually, websites just specify "named after months in the jewish calendar" and stop there.
After seeing this person on Tumblr kind of attack the game about its use of jewish names/references... it led me to do a few researches on my own. I went on various jewish websites and actually... I found some interesting stuff.
Nisan is a good example of what I'm talking about.
http://www.inner.org/times/nissan/nissan.htmNisan is also referred to as “the month of the redemption.” According to the accepted opinion of our sages: “In Nisan our forefathers were redeemed from Egypt and in Nisan we will be redeemed” (Rosh Hashanah 11a).
Nisan is a month of miracles, as its name stems from the Hebrew word for “miracles” (ניסים). The fact that the name Nisan (ניסן) possesses two nuns (נ and ן) implies according to the sages to “miracles of miracles” (ניסי ניסים). Of the future redemption, it is said: “As the days of your exodus from Egypt, I shall reveal to him wonders.” In Chassidut this verse is explained to mean that the wonders of the redemption of the future will be wondrous and miraculous even relative to the miracles of the Exodus from Egypt–hence “miracles of miracles.”
Another interesting page about Nisan : http://www.hebrew4christians.com/Holidays/Spring_Holidays/Rosh_Chodashim/rosh_chodashim.html
From what I gathered from searching multiple websites, "Nisan" is about "miracles", "redemption", "rebirth", "salvation", "deliverance", "spring", "flowers"... In Xenogears, the town is a religious center and becomes a place of salvation, of hope in disc 2. And its current leader is named Marguerite (this is a flower name). Not only that, but Nisan (and its leader Sophia... aka Elly... aka the one with the WE/God's will) was fighting a war for freedom against Solaris. "Nisan" is the first month in the jewish calendar as its represents jewish people's freedom from their oppressors (egyptians/pharaoh). As for rebirth... maybe Sophia "coming back" in the game illustrates this.
I could talk about the other months in details (I found out that there was a connection between Tammuz and Ezekiel... in short it's a "people worship this ancient god Tammuz and God gets angry about it" story... Ezekiel is the messenger... in Xenogears, Ezekiel is the name of the ship that attacks the Thames/Tammuz and the Ethos... I guess the Gazel = God, Ethos = the "unfaithful believers" and Thames = the "pagan" god/idol... since the Ethos was in partnership with the Thames to gather enough power to overthrow Solaris)... but I'm a bit tired and I'd like to know what you think about this.